Does Stillwater Insurance pay their employees well?

According to anonymously submitted Glassdoor reviews, Stillwater Insurance employees rate their compensation and benefits as 3.0 out of 5. Find out more about salaries and benefits at Stillwater Insurance. This rating has decreased by 7% over the last 12 months.

How satisfied are employees working at Stillwater Insurance?

42% of Stillwater Insurance employees would recommend working there to a friend based on Glassdoor reviews . Employees also rated Stillwater Insurance 3.1 out of 5 for work life balance, 3.1 for culture and values and 2.9 for career opportunities.

What are the top reviewed jobs at Stillwater Insurance?

Claims Adjuster (6) , Claims Examiner (6) , Customer Service Representative (6) , Business Analyst (3) , Customer Service Representative (CSR) (3) , Manager (3) , Analyst (2) , Claim Examiner (2) , Claims Examiner III (2) , Claims Representative (2) , Customer Service (2) , Senior Claims Examiner (2) , Software Engineer (2) , Underwriting Manager (2)

What are the pros of working at Stillwater Insurance according to real employee reviews?

"Great people to work with and for." ((in 8 reviews)); "The pay was good for what you are doing everyday" ((in 7 reviews)); "The CEO is amazing." ((in 5 reviews)); "Caring managers and leadership" ((in 4 reviews)); "New Claim VP started a month ago, and dissolved field units, Large Loss and all supervisors related to those teams." ((in 3 reviews))

What are the cons of working at Stillwater Insurance according to real employee reviews?

"The benefits could be better" ((in 6 reviews)); "Poor management, need to have a better process" ((in 4 reviews)); "Micromanaged, antiquated systems, too many portals to manage claims and minimal training." ((in 4 reviews)); "Supervisor management was not the same as upper management." ((in 4 reviews))

What are employees saying about Stillwater Insurance redundancies in 2026?

Explore Glassdoor’s employee reviews to understand what current and former employees are saying about Stillwater Insurance redundancy and their outlook for job security at Stillwater Insurance in 2026.

Stillwater Insurance Reviews

3.2

42% would recommend to a friend

(105 total reviews)

Mark Davey

64% approve of CEO

46% positive business outlook

Company ratings over time

Ratings trend for the last 6 months (105 reviews)

Stillwater Insurance has an employee rating of 3.2 out of 5 stars, based on 105 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Stillwater Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

105 reviews

3.0

28 May 2026

Remote work option available

Claims adjuster

Recommend

CEO approval

Business outlook

Pros

Remote working was available at the time.

Cons

Supervisor management was not the same as upper management.

4.0

13 May 2026

Helpful leadership and reasonable pay, but workload is unpredictable

Junior data analyst

Recommend

CEO approval

Business outlook

Pros

Predictable hours Helpful leadership Reasonable pay

Cons

Unpredictable workload Ad hoc request volume

Stillwater Insurance Response

4w

Thank you for taking the time to share your positive feedback. We will share your feedback with our IT department managers.

1.0

9 Jan 2026

Not a good company

Help desk technician

Recommend

CEO approval

Business outlook

Pros

A lot of room for growth and experience.

Cons

Horrible culture, the teams in the company across all departments do not like each other or work well with each other. Helpdesk is basically server admins needing to address server issues whether they are right after work or 3am and you will get yelled at if you don’t address it so expect to lost a lot of sleep.

Stillwater Insurance Response

5mo

We appreciate your feedback and will forward it to our leadership team for feedback on improving the team experience. Stillwater is committed to fostering an environment where employees are supported and valued and we strive to make Stillwater a great place to work. We wish you the best in your new position.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 105 Reviews

Jobs at Stillwater Insurance

Property Claim Adjuster

Property Claim Adjuster

Marketing Communications Designer

Jacksonville, FL

View job

Customer Service Representative - Remote

United States

View job

Customer Service Manager - remote

United States

View job