Paper Source Reviews

3.7

67% would recommend to a friend

(744 total reviews)

James Daunt

48% approve of CEO

35% positive business outlook

Paper Source has an employee rating of 3.7 out of 5 stars, based on 744 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Paper Source employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Retail and wholesale industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

744 reviews
2.0
28 Mar 2016

Unethical upper management

Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Managers and co-workers are friendly, hard-working, and team-oriented group of people. The work that I completed at Paper Source was for my team and never for the company.

Cons

Employees are abused by the company at all levels. I understand that a new CEO has been put into place, and so am hopeful that these issues will begin to be rectified because they need to be rectified soon. I am by no means a person with wild expectations for employee treatment --I've worked retail at a number of different places, have earned two degrees in my (unrelated/non-creative) field, have worked non-retail jobs too and never for pay higher than $20/hour. But speaking from the past few years of employment at Paper Source: -Managers cannot afford to take breaks during long hours because of the daily task expectations of corporate, many of which are unreasonably time-consuming creations for temporary display (cutting out elaborate paper designs, assembling dozens of tissue pom poms or rosettes, constant floor moves of products and complex signage, etc). I don't want to be an associate for a company in which I see my supervisors being abused daily by unrealistic expectations and little positive reinforcement. It lowers associate morale (or, at least, mine) because we are such a tight-knit team and want to see each other be treated well. There are 'incentives' like contests in which stores win candy, or small gift cards for pizza, etc. But there is no overtime compensation available to any managers or associates for required tasks when they go long after close. No overtime, either, for holidays, or floor-moves/inventories that could last until midnight or later. No bonus, and no commission for commission-style tasks (like selling custom print orders of $500+) and selling pricey workshop seats. -Low wages for high-energy-demand in the level of customer interaction, especially considering the baseline of knowledge (many employees have fine arts degrees) and service level required with things like custom print orders for brides/grooms, workshop instruction, display-building tasks etc. Assistant managers are paid low wages as well --just $11-12 to the associates' $9-10. I made the same amount of money working lower-responsibility retail jobs in *high-school* (sit at the register, do nothing) than I do here, and those businesses equipped themselves much larger staffs to spread tasks/ease workload for individual employees. Which brings me to the following point: -Store is consistently understaffed --rotating staff is so small that on-call workers are always being requested, and a lot of work consistently falls onto each individual person on a shift. Doesn't seem that payroll allows for enough workers in its rotation, and those workers who are there are not invested because so few hours are offered --but then little flexibility to have a second job. -Products are overpriced and occasionally culturally insensitive (teepees and 'Indians' for Thanksgiving packaged under Paper Source's own brand, sugar skulls as tchochke year-round, cards depicting nuns in heaven holding guns and alluding to the '72 virgins' trope of Islam, bow and arrow themed products, etc) with no attempt to rectify by corporate. I felt horrible/mortified having to sell and stock items that I thought were deeply offensive to the diverse community in which my Midwestern store resides. The fact that we have carried teepee table displays for 3 consecutive years, despite annual customer complaints relayed in the HindSight to corporate, indicates to me a lack of care about the customer base and region of operation. The Midwest is home to over half a million Native American-identifying people alone. Perhaps this is something the new CEO will better tend to. -Corporate directives are disorganized, unclear and typo-laden. An example of disorder: for 3 years corporate didn't even know that what it was asking us to do --clandestinely obtaining names from credit cards for registry numbers--was illegal. Totally unprofessional. -The pressure on the floor manager to make daily sales goals, which are often too high, trickles down to associates --who are sometimes asked (jokingly, and not) to purchase a few items at the end of the day to make goal. The idea that we spend our shifts selling such highly priced items (a stuffed animal for $40, for example) to wealthy customers who have the disposable income to afford our product (in fact, this is PS's consumer base) when so many of us are struggling paycheck to paycheck and returning home exhausted is deeply disappointing to me. This is not my industry/field and I have never planned for this job to be more than part-time as I pursue my other career--but for my coworkers who hope to make a living wage for the foreseeable future, I think Paper Source owes them much more.

2.0
22 Jul 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

My fellow co-workers. My fellow co-workers that I worked closely with everyday are amazing. They are friendly and kind and my fellow co-workers always had nice things to say everyday and were the only reason I stayed at the job for as long as I did. My salary was great as well.

Cons

My official title was executive assistant to the CEO. My initial red flag was that I was so much more than that. I was Front Desk secretary as well, PERSONAL AND EXECUTIVE assistant to not only the CEO but also the COO, and I dealt with all of the mail, and supply orders for the entire company. I was told to go on so many personal (and work related) errands, I booked doctors, dentist, hair appointments and so much more. I would also have to answer emails, calls and texts late at night and on the weekends while with family that I did not get paid for. This job consumed my life. And none of this was brought to my attention prior to accepting the job. Now through all of that, I personally struggle with mental health issues. I have severe anxiety, PTSD due to trauma, and depression. Well, when I got fired, I happened to be going through a really bad bought of depression. I felt as though I was fired based solely on bias reasons and not actually because I wasn't doing my job properly. I reached out first and sat down with Jenica (COO) and Winnie (CEO) in separate meetings and explained to them that I was struggling with my depression and anxiety - after they were concerns with my performance. I had tried to bring this to their attention multiple times. Paper Source is an at will employment agency, so they have the power to walk up to any employee and fire them without any notice. I felt as though this is what happened to me since I had tried to explain my situation. Both of my bosses were aware of my mental health issues and yet after meetings with them and talking with them about what I can do to improve, I was just fired a month later. The example given to me when fired was that I had lack of attention to detail, the example used was a specific situation where the COO had me use her company card to book her on a personal vacation. I did not realize this and I had booked her at a different airport than her family, and she was very unhappy with me. Paper source is clearly changing as a company. The employees are becoming more and more mistreated and fired without warning or compassion. It is a very stressful place to work because you are in constant fear of being fired for no reason.

2.0
26 Oct 2017

Same Stuff, Different Day, Same Old Mistakes

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

-Overall friendly employees/team members -Creative/crafty moments and opportunities -Experience with time-management and working in a team environment

Cons

-WEAK AND INCOMPETENT MANAGEMENT, which leads to stressed and depressed employees. Employees generally do not trust management, don't feel they can be honest about their grievances, trust that they'll follow through with promises and (much-needed) improvements, but keep getting told that they're heard and valued. Classic example of words not being met with actions. -Senior Leadership is completely oblivious as to how bad things are at the lower levels of the company and keep trying to "find the silver lining" to no avail. Morale is bad and it's going to get worse until they change their approach and start heeding the feedback of lower level employees, especially those on the front lines who have valuable insight into what customer's want and what their complaints are. -Many departments like IT and the web team are grossly understaffed (in the single-digits for both, or at least, that's how many are available to help at any given time), which the stores, HQ, and warehouse facilities depend on. If those teams can't get something done, it's like a ripple effect and other departments are stuck. -PERSISTENT SYSTEM ISSUES AND FAILURES, OUTDATED TECHNOLOGY. More times than not, you need to get "creative" with your solutions or work-arounds, because you cannot depend on what you have to work properly and when they do, you're just waiting for it to break. This includes the website, which stores and customers continue to have issues with. Are we getting a new site or what? Because right now, it's driving customers AWAY and infuriating stores when we can't get it to work. What we have now is not at all in league with the tech our competitors have. And oh, can't forget new roll-outs! Everyone knows when a new system, feature, or product gets rolled out, that it's a disaster on the site and/or the backend. We EXPECT it and it creates a lot of anxiety. -LOW COMPENSATION/SUBPAR BENEFITS, the first is below industry standards for pretty much any job title you can think of here. And the managers all know it and try to make light of it (they fail miserably). The "merit" increases have been suspended for this year, which has definitely contributed to the low morale, but they were really low to begin with and it's based on a percentage, not your performance. They don't pay anyone what they're worth here but they expect 100% from you at all times. Either they cannot compete financially for strong, competent, and reliable labor OR they're not willing to which leads to the next point... -HIGH TURNOVER. It's a red flag you should heed. Paper Source is a revolving door of employees. Paper Source really can't retain good employees and that will be their undoing. It's especially a disaster when it comes to the world of custom because there's so much to know! You have people that become experts in this really important portion of the business but because the company doesn't fight to keep their best employees happy, they leave and a store or team has to start from square 1 and scramble to make it work and take time to teach someone else. The stress and chaos that ensues is so frustrating and even moreso for customers. Reader, if you want a place that will run you ragged, cast breadcrumbs your way and tell you to be thankful, break promises, stress you with their company-wide inefficiencies, and provide you with a sense of hopelessness and disappointment, this is the place for you. You'll probably make some friends that feel EXACTLY as you do so at least you won't be alone in it; you'll all just suffer together for as long as you're there, until you decide you can do better or an opportunity presents itself.

avatar
Paper Source Response
8y
We take very seriously all feedback from current and past employees, as it helps us strengthen our inclusive culture. As a privately-held, mid-size company, we pride ourselves on avoiding the bureaucracy of a larger organization and value entrepreneurial spirit across all levels of the organization. As the retail landscape is changing, we are adjusting internally so we may continue to deliver the best customer experience possible. Thank you for the feedback as we continue to innovate.
Viewing 1 - 3 of 744 Reviews

Glassdoor has 775 Paper Source reviews submitted anonymously by Paper Source employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Paper Source is right for you.